This has been all over the internet the last few days. Artist Kyle Lambert did this digital painting of Morgan Freeman using ProCreate and an iPad… and his finger.¬¨‚Ä†According to the video, it took over 285,000 brush strokes and 200 hours of work.
This has elicited a lot of discussion and speculation on the internet about, among other things, the following:
1. Did he just trace a photo?
My two cents: Yes, he must have used a photo as an underlayer even though it is not seen in the video (easy to exclude from a screen capture video). No way could anyone do something that exactly perfect by translating what their eyes see and recreating that with their hands. Image overlays done by others show a nearly flawless reproduction. The human brain, eyeballs and motor skills just don’t work that perfectly together. Not that it matters, the impressive part of this is the exacting nature of the rendering done on something like the iPad.
2. Would this be copyright infringement of the original photograph?
My two cents: Yes, absolutely. There is no artistic interpretation here whatsoever. It is an exact reproduction of the original photo. It doesn’t matter if it was reproduced by hand taking over 200 hours, or scanned in under 15 seconds. Lambert credits the photographer but that is not the same as getting his copyright permission. Perhaps he did, I don’t know. If not, he needs to, unless the photographer has no interest in his copyright.
3. What’s the point?
My two cents: This is what it is: It’s a very impressive technical demonstration of someone creating something using a difficult platform that could have been created much faster and easier, and just as impressively, on another platform. That’s really the only point, that is was done on an iPad, which is amazing. The painting itself has no artistic interpretation or input, and wasn’t meant to have any. I’m not taking anything away from Lambert, he’s obviously a very talented digital painter… I wish I could paint one-millionth as well. No doubt when he brings his own artistic sensibilities into play he can do some impressive work, but this is just a demonstration of technical skill on an usual platform for such work, which I am sure is what was intended. It’s a little like building a vehicle like a Ford Explorer from scratch using hand-tooled parts, individually sculpted and carved pieces, and individually hand-created components. It might take thousands of hours to make, but in the end what you have is a Ford Explorer… made the hard way.
That said, I do not know why so many people are acting offended by this, like Lambert is somehow trying to pass this off as a great work of art or suggest it is supposed to be a commercial juggernaut of a style. I don’t think he is trying to do anything except demonstrate the technical possibilities of the software and hardware he used, which he clearly did very well. I’m quite sure he knows there is little commercial application for exact copies of photographs that were hand painted and took hundreds of hours to complete. He’s just demonstrating his technical skills with this platform… I hope he got some dough out of the makers of Procreate for his efforts.
…and I still hate working on an iPad. More power to you, Kyle.
UPDATE: Typically I would give the benefit of the doubt to the artist in a case like this, but this blog post and the data backing it up from fotoforensics seems to prove conclusively that not only was the actual photograph used in the creation of this image, but that PhotoShop CS 5 and 6 on a Macintosh was used in its creation. Since that directly refutes Lambert’s claims that at no time was the photo used, and that it was created exclusively on the iPad with Procreate, you have to question anything that he or Proceate claims. Of course the “proof” of the fraud could itself be a fraud… it’s the internet a wonderful place?
- Classic Rock Sketch Series (33)
- Freelancing (150)
- General (1,183)
- Illustration Throwback Thursday (38)
- It's All Geek to Me! (52)
- Just Because… (1)
- MAD Magazine (539)
- Mailbag (522)
- Monday MADness (169)
- News (757)
- On the Drawing Board (159)
- Presidential Caricatures (47)
- Sketch O'The Week (550)
- Surf's Up Dept. (29)
- Tales from the Theme Park (17)
- Tutorials (17)
- Wall of Shame (17)